| Jeff Barton | Terre Haute | 37 years old | | |
| Shanon Klocko | North Taylorville | 53 years old | | |
| Maryse Zemlak | South Antonia | 36 years old | | |
| Orin Runte | Huelside | 55 years old | | |
| Weldon Bernhard | Loganchester | 60 years old | | |
| Jacinto Marks | Lake Mistyboro | 58 years old | | |
| Albin Stark | Lake Rosannabury | 24 years old | | |
| Dameon Cremin | Labadieville | 48 years old | | |
| Newton Kunze | Williamsonstead | 27 years old | | |
| Brice Bosco | Tuscaloosa | 52 years old | | |
| Candice Hyatt | Lake Osvaldo | 64 years old | | |